Excellent back room for a friend's baby shower. Good service. Warm and cozy. I really enjoyed my salmon, sauce on the side. It was moist, flaky and tasted great. Potatoes and asparagus were just ok. Creme brûlée was delightful. I heard they have a great Sunday brunch I would love to go back to try it!

I really can't say enough about Rothman's. I'll start out with the sensational, professional and personalized service. And anyone who knows Rothman's, will know that here, you will be served the Best Steak Ever. Nobody on earth will serve a better porterhouse for two!! And all our sides were delicious and expertly prepared. By the way, the Rothman's Cabernet was an excellent wine choice, chosen by Rothman's very own Somelier!!! My favorite appetizer is the Huge Tomato and Onion, drizzled with Balsamic. Let Rothman's be your favorite place to break the bank once in a while, It's worth it!!!

So, I am only review the Sunday Buffet at Rothmann's. I thought the spread was very good with selection s from meat, to seafood to breakfast to sides. The steak is cut upon request and was well cooked and seasoned. The seafood was a cold selection with lobster, Shrimp, and oysters. There was no end to the amount of gluttony you could entertain. Everything was wonderful. After savory selection, there was about 20 different types of desserts, including a chocolate fountain. The staff was beyond , never did an empty plate sit on our table, our water was constantly filled, they checked on us expertly. The place is large with two dining rooms.

We came here for the AYCE brunch, which is on Sundays. For 70 bucks you get unlimited lobster, shrimp, crab, prime rib, skirt steak, and many more. I took video of all the food so you can see it all. The food was excellent and so was the service. I will definitely be back.

We visited Rothmann's Steak House recently for a birthday brunch and were thoroughly impressed! The seafood options, including lobster, crab legs, and shrimp, were absolutly amazing. The servers continually came around offering fresh melted butter to complement the seafood platters. The steak was juicy and tender, and I appreciated the generous portions cut each time I visited the buffet. The buffet area did get a bit congested, and the single omelet station had a notably long line. However, service was good, with prompt plate clearance and attentative staff. Overall, I'd highly recommend Rothmann's Steak House for its exceptional food quality and solid service. I'll definitely return.. Enjoy!!

Great value for all that you experience the prime rib was the best item . It was great Followed by the skirt steak Also very good The shrimp in my opinion were too small . Oysters and raw clams , meh The sushi was warm and were very basic. The espresso was very good The desserts were very good Complimentary Bloody Mary very good It's Worth it for the meats

The best steakhouse on Long Island. Sorry to those who love the others but Rothmann is beautifully traditional and of high quality. The first time we went, our son was about to be born. We celebrated right before I was induced and it was one of the best meals we ever had. That's why when Hubs asked what I wanted for my birthday, I knew it was time to come back. This place is pristine, and gives those old school steakhouse vibes. Legend has it Teddy Roosevelt himself dined here. It makes it extra special because we love going to Sagamore Hill several times a year. The food is amazing. The last time my hubs got a waygu but this time he got the New York strip. At a solid 16oz. There was a tiny piece of fat, but that strip was all meat and it was delish ( of course I snuck a piece). This time around I ordered fish - colossal shrimp with a lump crab avocado salad. The shrimp were in a miso glaze sauce that was quite tasty. And when they say colossal, they mean it. These shrimp were huge. Finally, I appreciate the staff and the attention to all their diners here. Not only did the wait staff check on us, two other managers did as well.